Everything Wrong With Knock at the Cabin in 19 Minutes or Less

  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Gallery
  4. »
  5. Videos
  6. »
  7. Everything Wrong With Knock

Knock at the Cabin is the latest M. Night movie and it’s based on a book, so of course he threw out the book’s ending and created his own. Sigh. Here are the sins.

Thursday: recent comic action sins.

Remember, no movie is without sin. Which movie’s sins should we count next?

•CinemaSins website•

•Channels•
–TVSins:
–MusicVideoSins:
–CommercialSins:
–CinemaSins Podcast Network:

•SinClub Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!•

•Merch!•

•Podcasts•
–Recotopia: A happy home for recommended movies, shows, & music from two people you can totally trust. Chris and Jeremy take turns picking a movie each week to recommend, as well as talk about other pop culture stuff they are consuming. Become a member of the SinClub to interact LIVE with them every week!
–Behind the Sins:The CinemaSins B-Team give you an unprecedented inside look at what goes on in the CinemaSins universe. Each week Aaron, Denee’, Jonathan, and Ian will break down the videos, YouTube comments, your questions and more!
–Captain’s Pod: A Star Trek companion podcast! Join Ian, Deneé, and a crew of intrepid guests as they boldly explore everything they love and, naturally, everything wrong with the franchise that has dominated the final frontier for more than half a century.

•Writers•
Jeremy:
Chris:
Aaron:
Jonathan:
Deneé:
Ian:
Daniel:

•Other Links•
Discord:
Reddit:
Jeremy’s Book:
Instagram:

Rate this post

549 Comments

Avatar of @tiarastokes3897
@tiarastokes3897
18.07.2026
Jonathan Groff?! Sins removed
Avatar of @FreeEerf-o1y
@FreeEerf-o1y
04.06.2026
Nah, single sex or same sex, they don't procreate. You have to be heterosexual to be able to procreate. That's just science and I'm sinning you for that
Avatar of @jordancarmack584
@jordancarmack584
29.04.2026
2:40 Neither black nor white are colors. One is the result of having all colors in equal measure and the other is the absolute absence of light and therefore color.
Avatar of @VixeyTeh
@VixeyTeh
23.04.2026
"Damn, for non-menecing people they are menecing pretty hard." got me chuckling. 😅
Avatar of @CYMotorsport
@CYMotorsport
23.04.2026
4:30 thinking the maginot line was a door in even the most generous of interpretations ding
Avatar of @Nicole4771
@Nicole4771
24.03.2026
Batista is really good.
Avatar of @IamRa-18
@IamRa-18
24.03.2026
How do you not use the pennywise “now we’re not strangers anymore” clip at the end when Jeremey gives a compilation of his crazy mind references
Avatar of @arod8377
@arod8377
24.03.2026
What is * I'm a good person * from?
Avatar of @Gumbocinno
@Gumbocinno
23.03.2026
1:15

"Energy Levle"

i can't believe you missed that
Avatar of @blugrass55
@blugrass55
23.03.2026
The ending is very different than the book's.
Avatar of @trombonerist2856
@trombonerist2856
22.03.2026
17:05 Pretty sure they filmed this at the Evergreene Dairy Bar in Southampton NJ. Pass by there just about every day. Pretty neat area. Great ice cream. And also on Route 70.
Avatar of @Desaki65
@Desaki65
22.03.2026
🎶To be fair...🎶 The grasshopper metaphor isn't wrapped up in the novel either. So, extra sin?
Avatar of @MiyahElise
@MiyahElise
20.03.2026
This movie was dumb
Avatar of @morecringe89
@morecringe89
20.03.2026
If the argument is that this movie is watchable because Bautista is in it...I can see rotten tomatoes is expanding lol
Avatar of @90sbaby1
@90sbaby1
20.03.2026
this would've been a short movie; there's no ultimatum here because the child is not biologically theirs. I'd offer that stupid child up to them and go on about my day; who wouldn't offer a foster kid up in a situation like that. Oh please.
Avatar of @ang3239
@ang3239
19.03.2026
But there is indeed a Route 70 that goes through the Pine Barrens where this movie was filmed. :)
Avatar of @gabbodelaparrawrites
@gabbodelaparrawrites
19.03.2026
"That I've become invisible to the eye." 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Avatar of @Corpsman01
@Corpsman01
19.03.2026
Han did the Kessel run!
Avatar of @DanBrizuela
@DanBrizuela
18.03.2026
Avatar of @thomasd3104
@thomasd3104
18.03.2026
There's also two dads in Moon Girl.
Avatar of @JDMdrifterboy7
@JDMdrifterboy7
18.03.2026
Does anybody know why he dislikes Comcast so much?
Avatar of @GoSoup12
@GoSoup12
17.03.2026
Absolutely love seeing the Dave Bautista appreciation in the comments. He’s a phenomenal actor and deserves his flowers.
Avatar of @Just4Fun-Zocker
@Just4Fun-Zocker
17.03.2026
The woke crowd should have destroyed that movie because the two dads were both white.
Avatar of @Tra_C
@Tra_C
17.03.2026
Watched this movie last weekend and it was exhausting.
Avatar of @genseven4616
@genseven4616
11.03.2026
I personally think M. Night is extremely over rated.
Avatar of @kandiikola
@kandiikola
11.03.2026
this is just a suggestion but you guys should totally do the movie Unicorn Wars! It’s one of the most visually appealing animated movies I’ve ever seen
Avatar of @vitorfrota940
@vitorfrota940
11.03.2026
I've spent a portion of the movie thinking they would realize in the end they have been duped into believing the apocalypse by a crazy cult. Wasn't Shyamalan's movies supposed to have the "Shyamalan plot twist" on the third act? Was the twist that the four horsemen were who they said they were? Because the movie went out of its way to tell us that since the start.
Avatar of @sweetbabyboo5
@sweetbabyboo5
08.03.2026
I enjoyed the movie. Bautista was amazing! You know the movie is good when most of the sins are petty.
Avatar of @gabrielsuhm2432
@gabrielsuhm2432
08.03.2026
Another sin: I actually live in Medford MA which is the town displayed on the ID at 14:10. The zip code is 02155, not 02127
Avatar of @mikesands4681
@mikesands4681
08.03.2026
They dodged the hard ending of the book
Avatar of @MaekarManastorm
@MaekarManastorm
07.03.2026
The victim mentality is the most true part of this whole movie , its always because im black or im gay or im a member of lbgtq123abc.
Avatar of @elizabethtippens9567
@elizabethtippens9567
07.03.2026
I wish this movie had the same end as the book I feel like it was so much darker and played into the theme so much better
Avatar of @brandanjames3697
@brandanjames3697
07.03.2026
Lol just watched this last night. Was actually pretty good I enjoyed it and I got it the first time around haha
Avatar of @tranquilthoughts7233
@tranquilthoughts7233
06.03.2026
Well, forcing a loving family to willingly sacrifice one of them to stop the apocalypse fits perfectly with the christian/muslim/jewish god's morality.
Avatar of @thewilsonsfamilytravels
@thewilsonsfamilytravels
06.03.2026
I agree with all of your send except the song on the playlist. It is actually very relevant because it’s a song that he has on there specifically for their a little girl telling her that his favorite thing to do is to be with her that’s why it does not match the rest of his playlist because it’s not normally a song he would listen to,


plus they needed it for the ending. Ha ha.
Avatar of @malbear5360
@malbear5360
06.03.2026
I wounder what would have happened to their plan if the family decided to not go to the Cabin! 😂😂
Avatar of @michaelspikes1506
@michaelspikes1506
04.03.2026
Great 👌 review
Avatar of @natelizzle4731
@natelizzle4731
04.03.2026
Sinning you +1 for not knowing she named her cats after the greatest rapper of all time... Jody high roller aka riff raff !!!
Avatar of @eaglerider1826
@eaglerider1826
04.03.2026
I quit watching halfway through . They placed too much emphasis on the gay couple . For me it is not entertainment .
Avatar of @BobTheAwesomeBob
@BobTheAwesomeBob
03.03.2026
This was an awful film
Avatar of @jeliarra
@jeliarra
03.03.2026
I have to give you a sin for not finding at least 500 sins for this movie.
Avatar of @nathanheckelman302
@nathanheckelman302
03.03.2026
Dave Bautista is the best wrestler to transition to Hollywood as actor, mam delivers no matter what role he plays. Also yes Humans as a species tend to be fairly stupid but most everyone with basic television or internet saw what happened with the Tsunami that hit Indonesia in 2006, a lot more people would have been running for the high ground.
Avatar of @nemonucliosis
@nemonucliosis
02.03.2026
Looks like a shitty movie.
Avatar of @mikycarney5779
@mikycarney5779
02.03.2026
We need to start standing up to this ludicrous ideology there is no such thing as a gay family, stop it
Avatar of @aleksandarradovanovic8496
@aleksandarradovanovic8496
02.03.2026
Out of all people, at least I thought M. Night would have the balls to end the movie based on a book's ending. Plus, that would fit the narrative of the movie way better than the actual movie's ending
Avatar of @TheLiquidKnight
@TheLiquidKnight
01.03.2026
Land Rover Disvovery starting after being left along for more than a few hours. +1,000 sins for lack of realism.
Avatar of @onewayturtles
@onewayturtles
01.03.2026
That's WAY too sunny for Cannon Beach.
Avatar of @GRasputin91
@GRasputin91
01.03.2026
Drax still hasn't mastered the art of standing so still he disappears. I could totally see him in the beginning standing behind Wen
Avatar of @damprat141
@damprat141
28.02.2026
The ending of the book is way better, yet that's not very shocking given the history of book adaptation

Comments are closed.