Everything Wrong With Knock at the Cabin in 19 Minutes or Less

  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Gallery
  4. »
  5. Videos
  6. »
  7. Everything Wrong With Knock

Knock at the Cabin is the latest M. Night movie and it’s based on a book, so of course he threw out the book’s ending and created his own. Sigh. Here are the sins.

Thursday: recent comic action sins.

Remember, no movie is without sin. Which movie’s sins should we count next?

•CinemaSins website•

•Channels•
–TVSins:
–MusicVideoSins:
–CommercialSins:
–CinemaSins Podcast Network:

•SinClub Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!•

•Merch!•

•Podcasts•
–Recotopia: A happy home for recommended movies, shows, & music from two people you can totally trust. Chris and Jeremy take turns picking a movie each week to recommend, as well as talk about other pop culture stuff they are consuming. Become a member of the SinClub to interact LIVE with them every week!
–Behind the Sins:The CinemaSins B-Team give you an unprecedented inside look at what goes on in the CinemaSins universe. Each week Aaron, Denee’, Jonathan, and Ian will break down the videos, YouTube comments, your questions and more!
–Captain’s Pod: A Star Trek companion podcast! Join Ian, Deneé, and a crew of intrepid guests as they boldly explore everything they love and, naturally, everything wrong with the franchise that has dominated the final frontier for more than half a century.

•Writers•
Jeremy:
Chris:
Aaron:
Jonathan:
Deneé:
Ian:
Daniel:

•Other Links•
Discord:
Reddit:
Jeremy’s Book:
Instagram:

Rate this post

434 Comments

Avatar of @scottieboy5429
@scottieboy5429
22.01.2026
The diner at the end doesn’t look like the one from the Unbreakable timeline…it looks like the one from The Happening 🫣 also the flash forward of Andrew stepping out of a building in a city block looks exactly like the street that Wahlberg and Deschenel (sp) live on in the Happening, after the Happening has Happened (((which also looks like one from Split, which has the same old lady Betty Buckley from The Happening))) lol I personally think this is linked to that movies timeline
Avatar of @franquil85conn
@franquil85conn
22.01.2026
There is plenty of reasons a school bus doesnt and shouldnt have seatbelts
Avatar of @johnnyallenshaneprater4870
@johnnyallenshaneprater4870
22.01.2026
I dont get why everyone is amazed that a guy who has been a pro wrestler his whole life is a good actor? Wrestling is fake all they do is act.. Its all show there is a script just like when you make a movie so of course Bautista is going to be a good actor hes been doing it his whole life, pretending to be hit
Avatar of @truthveritas8730
@truthveritas8730
20.01.2026
"Everything Right" is a shorter list. 1.) Bautista That's it.
Avatar of @Undertow6sic6
@Undertow6sic6
20.01.2026
Batista deserved to have enough sins removed on his own to counter the overall sin count. He was that good.
Avatar of @mattakins3422
@mattakins3422
20.01.2026
Is sabrina the mission lady from where in the world is carmen sandiego lady?
Avatar of @hinduismwithpremananddasbhagat
@hinduismwithpremananddasbhagat
18.01.2026
The movie was interesting. I hated the movie's ending.
Avatar of @fluffhead7892
@fluffhead7892
18.01.2026
The making this a feature film rather than just a 50 minute short (black mirror or something) is so true.
Avatar of @dustinjames8529
@dustinjames8529
18.01.2026
That Peaco- joke was great
Avatar of @thomassomeone4868
@thomassomeone4868
17.01.2026
Dave Bautista, my beloved.
Avatar of @jovianigonzales3507
@jovianigonzales3507
17.01.2026
I don't know if the book or movie explains it, but why do these four have to be sacrificed? All I saw was that their sacrifice unleashed chaos, what was the purpose?
Avatar of @sunnybains7638
@sunnybains7638
17.01.2026
Just watched it! What a waste of 2 hours!
Avatar of @raphaelcalado4335
@raphaelcalado4335
16.01.2026
This movie is much better than I thought it would be, even considering it’s religious and conspiracy undertones.
Avatar of @Divinecomedy232
@Divinecomedy232
16.01.2026
Bautista being so polite and cordial made his role so much more creepy. He was incredible in the film.
Avatar of @georgethomas4567
@georgethomas4567
16.01.2026
It's sad when not even 2 minutes in I was able to tell what the twist or big reveal would be. With them being the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. I think it's a well directed film, Dave Bautista is really giving it 100% but the actual story is just so slow and boring.
Avatar of @craigklein5563
@craigklein5563
15.01.2026
There is no point to this movie and it does not deliver any punchline. This movie is a twisted pile of nonsense!
Avatar of @Tater4200
@Tater4200
15.01.2026
"Procreate " 😂😂😂😂 thats a sin
Avatar of @dennisstrope8912
@dennisstrope8912
15.01.2026
I am so tired of the “same sex couples” crap being rammed down our throats! Next time I introduce friends, I going to say, “these are my straight friends Bob and Vera.”
NOBODY CARES
Avatar of @notabot3518
@notabot3518
14.01.2026
this episode was extremely karen-esque. what the hell happened to this channel
Avatar of @thatfishguy4991
@thatfishguy4991
14.01.2026
Fr I don’t get WHY they have to kill someone for each no like why not just NOT kill each other? Then there’d be no apocalypse and these poor gay people wouldn’t have to kill each other 😭
Avatar of @jnort95
@jnort95
14.01.2026
Great Video!
Avatar of @sarlaccstapeworm990
@sarlaccstapeworm990
12.01.2026
Movie has major misconceptions about the apocalypse! (DING! +50)

M. Night Shyamalan went 'woke'! (DING!! +100)

2 Dads! (DING!! +1,000)

Cinema Sins majorly UNDER sinned the movie! (DING! +50)

114 + 50 + 100 + 1,000 + 50 = 1,314
Avatar of @dudeman3973
@dudeman3973
12.01.2026
I think the perfect ending to this movie would be a twist (yes, I know that's a Shyamalan cliche) where they WEREN'T supposed to kill anyone to show the true love and compassion found in humanity.
Avatar of @scholarsacademy4946
@scholarsacademy4946
12.01.2026
Dave was outstanding ❤
Avatar of @drake.707
@drake.707
11.01.2026
Where was Harry?
Avatar of @2ToTheDome
@2ToTheDome
11.01.2026
i remember this, this movie was trash!😂
Avatar of @Dan_Hazard
@Dan_Hazard
11.01.2026
M Knight Shyalamalamadingdong
Avatar of @markm1138
@markm1138
10.01.2026
your channel is whats happening in your family
Avatar of @silenraven1017
@silenraven1017
10.01.2026
I wonder how the movie could have been if there was no real end or tv news saying everything just mysteriously stopped when Eric died. It would have been fun to try and figure if the cult is a real message of god or just a cult of crazy people who just wants to kill themselves and torture people
Avatar of @myonie22
@myonie22
10.01.2026
@8:17 Hereditary
Avatar of @Caldilsee
@Caldilsee
09.01.2026
The Bautista sin counter was necessary and so deserved. He was so good in this film
Avatar of @richhenry7540
@richhenry7540
09.01.2026
Loved the idea, concept, plot. Just, not the way it was executed.
Avatar of @Princesspandapop
@Princesspandapop
09.01.2026
This is now HP cannon! Ok!
Avatar of @Princesspandapop
@Princesspandapop
08.01.2026
Ok, I thought the HP thing had me, the damn edits at the end! 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Avatar of @sufferedlearnedchanged
@sufferedlearnedchanged
08.01.2026
Title of video says 19 minutes. However, title screen says 18 minutes.. which is it?!
Avatar of @katfield
@katfield
08.01.2026
You can't sin the movie for calling them a single-sex couple and not take a sin for saying that same-sex couples can procreate
Avatar of @seasonrain2061
@seasonrain2061
07.01.2026
The kid save the movie some of the actors where just too horrible specially that steroid muscle dude.

Comments are closed.